Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • About
    • About IJS
    • What Are Jewish Spiritual Practices?
    • Mission and Vision
    • Our Impact
    • People
    • IJS in the News
    • Foundation Support
    • Financial Statements
    • Career Opportunities
  • Resources
    • IJS Newsletter Sign Up
    • Calendar
    • Free Offerings
    • Kol Dodi Spiritual Director Listings
    • Shevet Young Adult Community
    • IJS Podcasts
    • Blog
    • Starter Kit
    • Books
    • Wise Aging
  • Online Programs
    • IJS Program Catalog
    • Spiritual Direction Groups
    • Text Study 5787
    • Mindful Winter Holidays
    • Awareness in Action
    • The Gift of Awareness
    • The Gift of Awareness for Educators
  • Retreats
    • Retreat for Younger Adults
  • Cohorts
    • Clergy Leadership Program
    • The Marbeh Fellowship: Cultivating Senior Jewish Mindfulness Teachers
    • Kivvun: Mindful Jewish Leadership
    • Kol Dodi Jewish Spiritual Director Training
    • Yesod: Foundations for Deepening Jewish Mindfulness Meditation
    • Alumni
      • Clergy Leadership Program
      • Hevraya Alumni Resources
      • Jewish Mindfulness Meditation Teacher Training
      • Amukah 1
      • Kivvun 2
      • Kivvun 3
      • Kivvun 4
      • Kivvun 5
  • Communities
    • Shevet: A Jewish Mindfulness Community for Young Adults
    • Shalem: A Monthly Mindfulness Affinity Space for People with Disabilities
    • Sharing our Torah: Jews of Color Mindfulness Affinity Sit
    • Segula: LGBTQ+ Monthly Mindfulness Sits
  • Contact
  • Login
  • Donate
    • DAF Gifts
    • Dedicate a Sit
    • Legacy Gifts
    • Monthly Giving
    • More Ways to Give
    • Donor Covenant
Select Page

Not About the Breath

Jul 8, 2015 | by Rabbi Lisa Goldstein, Former Executive Director, Institute for Jewish Spirituality, Email Newsletter Full Article | 2 comments

One of the great challenges of spiritual practice is not to confuse the form with the purpose. For example, when first learning to meditate, it is easy to assume that the practice is about noticing breath (or whatever the object of focus is) and that to be “successful” in meditation, you have to be able to sustain long, undistracted attention to the breath. But as we deepen the practice, it becomes clear that it is not actually about the breath at all. It is about many things: learning to live life with intentionality, noticing conditioning of all kinds, listening to the wisdom of the body, refining compassion and humility, cultivating dedication and concentration, just as a start. But it’s not really about the breath.

And yet, it actually is crucial to start with the breath. The breath is the form, the container through which these other benefits emerge. By using the structure of bringing attention to the breath, we can see more clearly what actually arises and experiment wisely with that. Occasionally we may be able to do this kind of work spontaneously without the form; sometimes the muse does strike us. But as spiritual practitioners (and good writers) know, more often than not, spontaneous wisdom and insight is a rare gift.

The same is true in prayer. Too often in the Jewish world we focus on mastering the form: the Hebrew, when to bow, sit or stand, all those words. In the world of Jewish prayer, it gets even more complicated, because, in fact, there isn’t just one form. We can work with the matbe’a (words of the prayer book), blessings, chanting, or hitbodedut (talking out loud to God)—each its own form to master. But in all cases, as we deepen our prayer practice, it becomes clear that it is actually not about the form. Just like in meditation, the form is the structure through which different kinds of experiences and experimentation can happen. Perhaps it is about opening the heart to God. Perhaps it is about opening the heart at all. Perhaps it is about cultivating gratitude and wonder or going deep into the unknown.

One way to differentiate between the form and purpose of spiritual practice is to practice with intention: Why am I doing this practice? What am I hoping or aiming for? Asking these question helps keep the form fresh. It infuses the form with possibility, with creativity, with aliveness. It is one of the things that can help make practice not rote, but transformational.

2 Comments

  1. Ruth Rosenblum
    Ruth Rosenblum on July 15, 2015 at 6:31 pm

    Thanks for this lovely essay, Lisa. I very much appreciate your writing about “form [be it breath focus or prayer] as structure” through which we can notice what we are actually experiencing and can cultivate the skills and traits that lead to real expansion and transformation. I’m making copies for all the students/practitioners in my Jewish Mindfulness Meditation groups here in Westchester county.

  2. Teréz Stolze
    Teréz Stolze on July 21, 2015 at 4:24 am

    More and more i come to see that all doing in life needs a form – that is – throuhg form it becomes a-life.
    Difficult to explain.
    What i read is another example. And here it is called ‘intension’.
    I could easily call it ‘searching’.
    Thank you.

Categories

  • Blog
  • by Firkins Reed, Director of Program Operations, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Kohenet Keshira haLev Fife, Core Faculty, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Max Bamberger
  • by Rabbi Barry Dolinger (CLP1)
  • by Rabbi Jordan Bendat-Appell, Senior Core Faculty, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Rabbi Lisa Goldstein, Former Executive Director, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Rabbi Marc Margolius, Senior Core Faculty and Senior Advisor, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Rabbi Miriam Margles, Senior Core Faculty, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Rabbi Myriam Klotz, Senior Core Faculty, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Rabbi Nancy Flam, Founding Teacher, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Rabbi Sam Feinsmith, Senior Core Faculty, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Rabbi Shefa Gold
  • by Rabbi Sheila Peltz Weinberg
  • by Rebecca Schisler, Core Faculty, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • by Yael Shy, Sefira Wellness
  • Day of Practice 2026
  • Elections
  • Email Newsletter Full Article
  • IJS
  • In the News
  • Institute of Jewish Spirituality
  • Live Sessions
  • Meditation
  • Open My Heart
  • Podcasts
  • Press Releases
  • Rabbi Josh Feigelson, PhD, President & CEO, Institute for Jewish Spirituality
  • Senior Program Director
  • Uncategorized

Archives

An Open-Armed Embrace (Chayei Sarah 5787)

An Open-Armed Embrace (Chayei Sarah 5787)

Nov 5, 2026

You may know the old Chinese story about the farmer and his son. A farmer experiences a series of alternately tragic and wonderful events: a runaway horse, a sudden windfall of wild horses, his son’s broken leg, his son exempted from the army draft because of said broken leg. In each instance, the farmer’s neighbors rush to declare the outcome a catastrophe or a blessing. But in each case the...

read more
Mindful Torah Wisdom: Chayyei-Sarah with Rabbi Sam Feinsmith

Mindful Torah Wisdom: Chayyei-Sarah with Rabbi Sam Feinsmith

Nov 4, 2026

Chayyei-Sarah: Unifying Heaven and Earth¹ According to the Hasidic masters, it’s to become an embodied bridge between Heaven and Earth.We find a blueprint for this in Avodat Yisrael, an 18th-century Hasidic commentary on Parashat Chayyei-Sarah: R. Yisrael Hopstein², Sefer Avodat Yisrael, Chayyei-Sarah, s.v. V’haMelekh David zaken ba bayamim  Our teacher Reb Barukh³ explained the verse...

read more
Vayera 5787

Vayera 5787

Oct 28, 2026

There’s a wonderful story about the great Hasidic master, Rabbi Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev. One day, he arrived in Lviv and approached the home of a wealthy, distinguished resident.   “Might I find a place in your home to spend the night?” he asked, without revealing his identity. “I have no room for wayfarers. Go to an inn,” the wealthy man replied. “A small corner in one of your rooms will be...

read more
« Older Entries

GET OUR MONTHLY NEWSLETTER

Success!

Subscribe

FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL

  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow

© 2024 Institute for Jewish Spirituality. All Rights Reserved.

Manage Consent

This site uses cookies to enhance your experience. By continuing to browse, you're agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn more in our privacy policy. 

Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
  • Manage options
  • Manage services
  • Manage {vendor_count} vendors
  • Read more about these purposes
View preferences
  • {title}
  • {title}
  • {title}